State of Himachal Pradesh v. Union of India, ORGNL.SUIT No.-000002-000002 - 1996
Bench: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE, HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JOYMALYA BAGCHI, HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE V. MOHANA (3 judges). Judgment by HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
Court fixes Himachal's energy arrears at 13,066 MU, payable over 20 lean seasons with cashless capital-cost set-off
Facts that mattered
The State of Himachal Pradesh sued under Article 131 claiming a share in power from the Bhakra-Nangal and Beas Hydro-Electric Projects built largely on its territory but enjoyed by composite Punjab and, after the 1966 reorganisation, by Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Chandigarh.
By judgment dated 27.09.2011 the Court decreed the suit in part, holding the Plaintiff-State entitled to 7.19% of power attributable to composite Punjab and directing the Union of India to compute the amounts due.
The Union of India computed arrears of 13,066 million units and a capital-cost liability, but Punjab and Haryana disputed the computation, leading to prolonged settlement efforts through the Attorney General.
The Court adopted a cashless settlement: 13,066 MU supplied over 20 lean seasons, with capital-cost liability of Rs. 420.77 crores adjusted against about 1,093 MU at Rs. 3.85 per unit, leaving about 11,973 MU payable.
Legal concepts
Proceedings to give effect to an earlier decree of the Court are in the nature of execution proceedings and cannot be used to reopen or re-agitate issues conclusively settled by that decree.
Laid down · para 30
Directions issued by the Court in implementation of its decree are binding and must be acted upon without reservation, and a decree cannot be rendered fruitless by the unwillingness or recalcitrance of a judgment debtor.
The Chairman National Book Trust India . v. Ar Abdul Gaffar ., C.A. No.-014369-014369 - 2015
Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHREE CHANDRASHEKHAR (2 judges). Judgment by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA
National Book Trust held to be a State under Article 12 of the Constitution
Facts that mattered
The National Book Trust was created by Government resolutions of 1957 and 1962 to produce and disseminate literature at moderate prices.
Its Rules place the Government-appointed Chairman, who holds office at the Government's pleasure, and Ministry nominees at the core of its governing and Executive Committees.
Financial administration, accounts, CAG audit, annual reports and rule alterations all require governmental involvement or approval.
The Delhi High Court Full Bench held the Trust to be a State under Article 12, and the Supreme Court was asked to decide that question on appeal.
Legal concepts
A body is a State under Article 12 if, on cumulative facts, it is financially, functionally and administratively dominated by or under the Government's control, such control being particular to the body and pervasive.
Reaffirmed · para 25
Registration as a society or the legal form of incorporation does not by itself take a body outside Article 12; the inquiry is into the substance of its relationship with the Government, not its nomenclature.
Reaffirmed · para 10 · Ajay Hasia and Others vs. Khalid Mujib Sehravardi and Others, (1981) 1 SC 722, para 7
The existence of a public or educational function, in isolation, is insufficient to make a body a State; cumulative satisfaction of the Article 12 test is required.
Reaffirmed · para 18 · Zee Telefilms Ltd. and Another vs. Union of India and Others, (2005) 4 SCC 649, para 18
Declaring a body a State under Article 12 does not convert it into a government department or make its employees civil servants, and has no automatic consequence under Articles 309, 310 or 311.
Yusuf v. Vigyapan Loke Delhi Advertising C.g.h.s. Ltd, C.A. No.-014175-014175 - 2026
Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKRAM NATH, HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH (2 judges). Judgment by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKRAM NATH
Balance sheet entries up to 2013 renewed limitation, so plaint rejection under Order VII Rule 11 was set aside.
Facts that mattered
The original plaintiff filed a summary suit in 2014 under Order XXXVII CPC to recover money under a civil works contract dated 10.02.2000, relying on running bills from 2000 to 2003.
The defendant sought rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, contending the suit was barred by limitation and disclosed no cause of action.
The Trial Court rejected that application, finding balance sheet entries from 2004 to 2013 amounted to acknowledgment of debt giving a fresh period of limitation.
The High Court allowed the defendant's revision, holding the entries did not establish acknowledgment beyond 2005, and rejected the plaint as time-barred.
Legal concepts
Section 18 of the Limitation Act does not require acknowledgment to be made to the creditor's name specifically or in a fixed format, so long as it acknowledges a subsisting liability.
Laid down · para 14
Entries in books of account, including balance sheets, may constitute an acknowledgment of liability under Section 18, assessed in the context of the balance sheet as a whole including notes and auditor's report.
Reaffirmed · para 10
At the stage of an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the Court must only assess whether the plaint discloses a prima facie case and not conclusively determine non-existence of liability on evidence.
Laid down · para 15
Where entries constitute acknowledgment under Section 18, a fresh period of limitation automatically runs from each subsequent acknowledgment, so no condonation of delay is required.
Union of India v. Rohith Nathan and Anr Etc., MA-003313-003315 - 2026
Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA, HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R. MAHADEVAN (2 judges). Judgment by HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R. MAHADEVAN
Court holds its OBC creamy-layer ruling binds parties only and cannot reopen concluded selections.
Facts that mattered
Respondent candidates who cleared the Civil Services Examination were denied OBC non-creamy layer benefits because DoPT applied the income test under the 1993 OM read with the 2004 Letter to their PSU-employed parents.
They succeeded before the CAT and the High Courts, and this Court dismissed the Union's civil appeals on 11.03.2026, directing implementation within six months.
The Union filed miscellaneous applications seeking prospective operation of the judgment, time to establish equivalence of posts, and protection for completed selections, appointments and admissions.
The CSE-2025 result was declared on 06.03.2026, but service allocation remained pending when the applications were heard.
Legal concepts
The binding force of a legal principle declared under Article 141 is distinct from the scope of the operative relief, which remains confined to the parties to the lis.
Laid down · para 13
Miscellaneous applications cannot be used to seek a rehearing or reconsideration of merits; they lie only for correcting clerical or arithmetical errors or resolving genuine implementation difficulties.
Reaffirmed · para 16
A ratio laid down by the Court does not by itself furnish a ground for reopening selections or appointments already concluded before the judgment, and does not operate to the detriment of others' seniority.
Laid down · para 18
Selections, appointments and roster allotments made after the judgment are governed by the 1993 OM as interpreted by the Court, while policy on equivalence of posts and creamy-layer criteria remains with the executive and legislature.
The appellants were appointed as Peons in 1989 and 1993, promoted to Assistant Grade-III in 2012 and 2013, and regularised in 2015.
A Government Circular dated 25 April 2017 directed review of service records of servants with 20 years service or 50 years age for compulsory retirement.
A Screening Committee applied uniform numerical scoring to 14 clerical employees and recommended 5, including the appellants, for compulsory retirement on 9 October 2017.
The High Court declined to interfere, and the Supreme Court affirmed, finding the parameters uniformly applied and the orders neither punitive nor stigmatic.
Legal concepts
An order of compulsory retirement is neither punitive nor stigmatic, so audi alteram partem and Article 311(2) do not apply to it.
Reaffirmed · para 24 · Baikuntha Nath Das & Anr. vs. Chief District Medical Officer, Baripada & Anr., (1992) 2 SCC 299, para 24
Compulsory retirement rests on the subjective satisfaction of the competent authority, but that satisfaction must be based on valid material on record.
Reaffirmed · para 25 · Nand Kumar Verma vs. State of Jharkhand & Ors., (2012) 3 SCC 580, para 25
An employee cannot assail compulsory retirement merely because another officer with a comparable record was not similarly retired; Article 14 does not countenance negative equality.
Reaffirmed · para 29
The principle that adverse entries lose sting on promotion applies only to entries pre-dating the promotion, not to entries recorded after promotion in the promoted post.
Laid down · para 39
An order of compulsory retirement is not liable to be quashed merely because uncommunicated adverse remarks were also taken into consideration.
A John Kennedy v. State of Tamil Nadu, C.A. No.-006395-006397 - 2025
Court excludes outside and temporary residents from FRA claims and orders supervised adjudication
Facts that mattered
The Court's earlier judgment mandated eviction, rehabilitation and ecological restoration in the Agasthyamalai landscape, including removal of encroachments and action against identified government servants.
Applications raised issues about applicability of the FRA, 2006 to persons residing or cultivating in the Megamalai region, and the State was directed to respond on silk cotton cultivation, pattas, action against 118 government servants, and FRA claim status.
The State's affidavit classified occupiers into three categories: 1,595 permanently residing in the forest, 232 with temporary residence, and 2,767 residing outside the forest boundary, with 3,637.83 hectares under silk cotton cultivation.
Around 40 Gram Sabhas had been constituted and about 1,600 claims received, with the State seeking time to complete the statutory adjudication process.
Legal concepts
Claims of FDST and OTFD must be determined strictly through the Section 6 three-tier mechanism read with the Rules, not on the basis of present occupation, and only persons satisfying Sections 2(c) and 2(o) get the Act's benefit.
Laid down · para 55
Persons cultivating with only temporary residence in the forest or residing outside the forest boundary cannot qualify as FDST or OTFD on the basis of such cultivation alone.
Laid down · para 64
Planned or promoted cultivation of a commercial crop inside forest areas is impermissible as no such right is recognised under the FRA, 2006, since minor forest produce must be naturally occurring.
Laid down · para 61
The FRA, 2006 is a social welfare or remedial statute enacted to recognise and vest forest rights of forest-dwelling STs and other traditional forest dwellers whose rights could not be recorded.
Reaffirmed · para 44 · Orissa Mining Corpn. Ltd. v. Ministry of Environment & Forests, (2013) 6 SCC 476, para 44
J.rajesh(minor) Thr. His Mother and Natural Guardian J. Gomathi v. M. Kumaran . (dead) Thr. Lrs., C.A. No.-007020-007020 - 2012
Grandfather's property passing to Class I heirs on partition is not coparcenary; grandson has no right by birth
Facts that mattered
A minor filed a 1997 suit seeking partition and possession of half share in land, claiming it was joint family property of his grandfather N. Ramakrishnan inherited by his father, the first defendant.
The grandfather's daughter had filed a partition suit in 1993, decreed by compromise on 03.02.1994, under which the first defendant got 1811 sq. ft.; the appellant was born on 06.01.1994.
The first defendant sold the property to defendants 2 and 3 in 1997; the trial court granted a preliminary partition decree but the High Court set it aside, holding the father became absolute owner.
The appellant challenged the sale but never challenged the compromise decree or the sale deeds, and the father remained ex parte throughout.
Legal concepts
Under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, property of a Hindu male dying intestate devolves on Class I heirs simultaneously to the exclusion of all other heirs, and a son's son is not a Class I heir.
Reaffirmed · para 34
Upon partition among Class I heirs, each heir becomes exclusive owner of the property falling in his share and the property ceases to be joint family property as heirs succeed as tenants in common, not joint tenants.
Reaffirmed · para 35 · Bhanwar Singh Vs. Puran and others, (2008) 3 SCC 87, para 30
A grandson cannot claim coparcenary rights by birth in his grandfather's property where succession opened before his birth and he was not a surviving coparcener at the grandfather's death.
This digest summarises Supreme Court of India judgments for general information. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Please read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.