Skip to main content
H.

Service law · Art. 226 · Judgment of

Removal of constable for 99-day overstay set aside as grossly disproportionate

The facts

  • The appellant, a CRPF constable, took casual leave for his wife's illness but overstayed by 99 days, failing to respond to two registered letters directing him to report for duty.
  • He produced medical documents showing treatment for infective hepatitis, but the Enquiry Officer disbelieved them because they lacked an outpatient number and appeared written with the same pen.
  • The Enquiry Officer inferred fabrication without verifying with the treating doctor or medical establishment, and removal from service was imposed.
  • The Division Bench restored the removal, holding the Single Judge had reappreciated evidence, but the Supreme Court found the rejection of medical documents rested on conjecture.

What the Court held

High Court may interfere in disciplinary matters only where natural justice is violated, statutory rules breached, extraneous considerations influenced the decision, or the conclusion is wholly arbitrary and capricious.

Reaffirmed · para 8 · State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. v. S. Sree Rama Rao, 1963 SCC OnLine SC 6, para 8

Other principles

  • Disciplinary and appellate authorities are fact-finding bodies with exclusive power to consider evidence; courts cannot normally substitute their own conclusion on penalty unless it shocks the conscience.

    Reaffirmed · para 9

  • Unauthorised absence and wilful absence are not necessarily synonymous; the circumstances of absence, the explanation furnished, and supporting material must be considered before determining the nature and gravity of misconduct.

    Laid down · para 10

  • The punishment imposed must satisfy the requirement of proportionality to the magnitude and gravity of the misconduct, even for members of a disciplined force.

    Reaffirmed · para 13

Summaries are for information and are not legal advice. Read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.