Since the Prevention of Corruption (Amendment) Act, 2018 (16 of 2018) came into force on 26 July 2018, the person who gives a bribe commits an offence in his own right. Section 8(1) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 makes it an offence to give or promise to give an undue advantage to a public servant with the intention of inducing improper performance of a public duty. Section 9 makes a commercial organisation liable by fine, and Section 10 makes a director, manager, secretary or other officer personally liable where the offence was committed with that officer's consent or connivance. Two provisos to Section 8(1) excuse a giver who acted under compulsion, and one carries a reporting duty of seven days from the date the undue advantage was given.
What Section 8(1) requires the prosecution to prove
Section 8(1) reaches any person who gives or promises to give an undue advantage to another person or persons, with the intention either to induce a public servant to perform improperly a public duty or to reward such public servant for the improper performance of a public duty. The punishment is imprisonment for a term which may extend to seven years, or fine, or both, and the intention is the element, so a prosecution does not have to show that the public duty was in fact performed improperly.
The Illustration to Section 8(1) sets out the ordinary case: a person "P" gives a public servant "S" ten thousand rupees to ensure that he is granted a license over all the other bidders, and "P" is guilty of an offence under that sub-section. The Explanation to Section 8(1) makes two points. It is immaterial whether the person to whom the undue advantage is given or promised is the same person as the person who is to perform, or has performed, the public duty concerned, and it is immaterial whether the advantage is given or promised directly or through a third party.
"the sum of Rs.50,00,000 became the proceeds of a crime only when Andasu Ravinder (A1) accepted it as a bribe." Directorate of Enforcement v. Padmanabhan Kishore, 31 October 2022, quoting the judgment of the High Court of Judicature at Madras.
The two provisos that excuse a giver who was compelled
The first proviso to Section 8(1) provides that the section does not apply where a person is compelled to give such undue advantage. The second provides that the person so compelled shall report the matter to the law enforcement authority or investigating agency within a period of seven days from the date of giving such undue advantage. The first removes the offence, and the second attaches a duty to the person who relied on it, the seven days running from the giving.
Section 8 does not define compulsion or name the officer who receives the report, and whether the facts show compulsion is a question for the officer or the court. The account the giver gives at the report is the first document on the point.
Section 8(2) deals with the informer. Nothing in sub-section (1) applies to a person who, after informing a law enforcement authority or investigating agency, gives or promises to give any undue advantage to another person in order to assist that authority or agency in its investigation of the offence alleged against the latter. The payment there assists the investigation, and a person who pays first and reports later has no route into Section 8(2).
When a commercial organisation is liable
Section 9(1) applies where an offence under the Act has been committed by a commercial organisation. The organisation is punishable with fine if any person associated with it gives or promises to give any undue advantage to a public servant intending to obtain or retain business for the organisation, or to obtain or retain an advantage in the conduct of business for it. The third proviso to Section 8(1) says the same from the other side: a commercial organisation shall be punishable with fine.
The defence is stated in the proviso to Section 9(1): it is a defence for the commercial organisation to prove that it had in place adequate procedures in compliance with the guidelines prescribed to prevent persons associated with it from undertaking such conduct. Section 29A(2)(a) allows the Central Government to make rules providing for guidelines which can be put in place by a commercial organisation under Section 9. Whether any guidelines have been prescribed is a point to check in the notifications under Section 29A.
Section 9(2) removes one further objection. For the purposes of Section 9, a person is said to give or promise to give any undue advantage to a public servant if he is alleged to have committed the offence under Section 8, whether or not such person has been prosecuted for it. The corporate charge does not wait for the employee's conviction.
Who counts as a commercial organisation and who counts as associated
Section 9(3)(a) defines "commercial organisation" in four limbs: a body incorporated in India carrying on a business, whether in India or outside India; a body incorporated outside India carrying on a business or part of a business in any part of India; a partnership firm or any association of persons formed in India carrying on a business, whether in India or outside India; and a partnership or association of persons formed outside India carrying on a business or part of a business in any part of India. Section 9(3)(b) provides that "business" includes a trade or profession or providing service.
Section 9(3)(c) defines who is associated: a person who performs services for or on behalf of the commercial organisation, irrespective of any promise to give or giving of any undue advantage which constitutes an offence under sub-section (1). Explanation 1 to Section 9 says that the capacity in which the person performs services shall not matter, whether the person is an employee, an agent or a subsidiary. The associate is defined by the work done.
Explanation 2 to Section 9 continues in the statute beyond the text available for this post. A lawyer reading the file should read the full explanation in the Gazette copy before taking a position on how far the section reaches.
When a director or manager is personally liable
Section 10 attaches personal liability to a director, manager, secretary or other officer of a commercial organisation where an offence under Section 9 is committed by the organisation and the court proves it was committed with the consent or connivance of that officer. The officer is guilty of the offence, is liable to be proceeded against, and is punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three years and may extend to seven years, and is also liable to fine. The Explanation to Section 10 says that "director", in relation to a firm, means a partner in the firm.
Aneeta Hada v. Godfather Travels, (2012) 5 SCC 661, bears on the position of the person who represents a company when the company is prosecuted, and on the fiction that extends vicarious criminal liability to the officers of a company only where the offence is committed by the company itself. Read with Section 10, the officer is charged only on proof of consent or connivance.
Where Section 12 abetment sits beside a Section 8 charge
Section 12 makes the abetment of an offence punishable under the Act an offence in its own right, and it applies whether or not that offence is committed in consequence of the abetment. The punishment is imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three years but which may extend to seven years, and a fine. A charge sheet may frame an arrangement to have a public servant accept money as abetment of the receiving offence under Section 7, and the punishment under Section 12 does not depend on the money being accepted.
Sections 8 and 9 beside the Prevention of Money Laundering Act
The Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (15 of 2003) sits alongside these sections, and the connection runs through its Schedule. In Directorate of Enforcement v. Padmanabhan Kishore, 31 October 2022, a Criminal Appeal arising out of Special Leave Petition (Criminal) No. 2668 of 2022, judgment of Uday Umesh Lalit CJI, the facts were these. On intelligence, the Central Bureau of Investigation checked a car parked in front of the house of an Additional Commissioner of Income Tax in Chennai on 29 August 2011 and recovered Rs 50,00,000 in cash, and the respondent was in the car. By its final judgment and order dated 1 March 2021 in Writ Petition No. 25670 of 2019, the High Court of Judicature at Madras held that the money became the proceeds of a crime only when the public servant accepted it as a bribe, and quashed the proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 against the respondent.
The judgment sets out paragraph 8 of Part A of the Schedule to the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, which lists the Prevention of Corruption Act offences: Section 7, Section 7A, Section 8, Section 9, Section 10, Section 11, Section 12, Section 13 and Section 14. Section 8 and Section 9 are in that list, so an offence under either is a scheduled offence. The respondent stands charged with conspiracy to commit offences punishable under Sections 7, 12 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Section 18A applies the Criminal Law Amendment Ordinance, 1944 to attachment, save as otherwise provided under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.
What a company should have in place before a complaint arrives
A company facing a complaint that its employee paid an official has a short list of documents. The defence in Section 9(1) asks whether the organisation had adequate procedures in place in compliance with the guidelines prescribed under Section 29A(2)(a), so the file should carry the written policy on payments to public servants, the authority under which it was issued, the training records, the register of gifts and hospitality, and the last audit of the policy. If guidelines have been notified, the notification belongs with the policy.
- the date the undue advantage was given and the date the company learned of it, in writing, since the seven days under the second proviso to Section 8(1) run from the giving;
- the training records for the staff who deal with officials, and the audit of the policy;
- the register of gifts and hospitality given to public servants;
- the report made to the law enforcement authority or investigating agency, where the company has relied on the first proviso to Section 8(1).
For the individual case, the periods to run are the seven days under the second proviso to Section 8(1) and the trial period, which under Section 4(4) is to be held as far as practicable on a day to day basis and is to be concluded within two years, extendable by six months at a time for reasons recorded in writing, the aggregate not to exceed ordinarily four years. Before the next hearing, read Section 8(1) with its three provisos and the Illustration, Section 9(1) with the proviso, Section 10 with its Explanation, and Section 29A(2)(a), then check the notifications under Section 29A for the prescribed guidelines.