Skip to main content
H.

Constitution of India · Art. 131 · Judgment of

Court fixes Himachal's energy arrears at 13,066 MU, payable over 20 lean seasons with cashless capital-cost set-off

The facts

  • The State of Himachal Pradesh sued under Article 131 claiming a share in power from the Bhakra-Nangal and Beas Hydro-Electric Projects built largely on its territory but enjoyed by composite Punjab and, after the 1966 reorganisation, by Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Chandigarh.
  • By judgment dated 27.09.2011 the Court decreed the suit in part, holding the Plaintiff-State entitled to 7.19% of power attributable to composite Punjab and directing the Union of India to compute the amounts due.
  • The Union of India computed arrears of 13,066 million units and a capital-cost liability, but Punjab and Haryana disputed the computation, leading to prolonged settlement efforts through the Attorney General.
  • The Court adopted a cashless settlement: 13,066 MU supplied over 20 lean seasons, with capital-cost liability of Rs. 420.77 crores adjusted against about 1,093 MU at Rs. 3.85 per unit, leaving about 11,973 MU payable.

What the Court held

Proceedings to give effect to an earlier decree of the Court are in the nature of execution proceedings and cannot be used to reopen or re-agitate issues conclusively settled by that decree.

Laid down · para 30

Other principles

  • Directions issued by the Court in implementation of its decree are binding and must be acted upon without reservation, and a decree cannot be rendered fruitless by the unwillingness or recalcitrance of a judgment debtor.

    Laid down · para 43

Summaries are for information and are not legal advice. Read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.