Skip to main content
H.

Companies Act, 2013 · s. 241 · Judgment of

Third-party purchaser protected by indoor management doctrine; sale deed restored

The facts

  • A mother filed a petition under s. 241 of the Companies Act, 2013, alleging her son sold company land without any valid board meeting and without her notice.
  • The NCLT declared the board resolution and sale deed void ab initio, directed cancellation of the registered document, and ordered refund of the sale consideration.
  • The NCLAT upheld the NCLT, finding no evidence of a board meeting on 01.08.2015 and that the sale lacked proper board authorisation.
  • The Supreme Court noted the mother had signed audited accounts and notes disclosing the sale, and drew an adverse inference against the company for not producing income tax returns.

What the Court held

The Doctrine of Indoor Management applies to protect an unrelated third-party purchaser who has no knowledge of the internal affairs of a company.

Laid down · para 20

Other principles

  • A third-party purchaser cannot be made liable for proving the holding of a board meeting and passing of a resolution; that burden lies on the shareholders and directors.

    Laid down · para 19

  • A director who signs books of accounts disclosing a transaction cannot later deny the transaction or claim ignorance of it.

    Laid down · para 25

Summaries are for information and are not legal advice. Read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.