Service law · Art. 226 · Judgment of
Supreme Court quashes removal of CISF constable as shockingly disproportionate, orders reinstatement
The facts
- The appellant, a CISF constable, sought leave to care for his wife suffering pregnancy complications and miscarriage; his further leave request was declined and he tendered a conditional resignation on 06.12.2017 under mental stress.
- He was charged under Rule 36 of the CISF Rules, 2001 with disobeying an order to appear, intimidating the administration through relatives circulating a video, and a history of five minor penalties.
- His requests for Hindi translations of English documents and for a defence assistant were rejected; translations were supplied only after prosecution evidence and his own examination had closed.
- The Inquiry Officer found all charges proved and he was removed from service; the High Court upheld the penalty, but the Supreme Court quashed it and ordered reinstatement with 50% back wages.
What the Court held
A punishment so disproportionate to the misconduct proved as to shock the conscience of the Court is arbitrary and offends Article 14, justifying interference.
Reaffirmed · para 13 · Bhagat Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors., (1983) 2 SCC 442, para 13
Other principles
Interference in disciplinary matters is warranted where proceedings violate natural justice or statutory rules, findings are unsupported by evidence, or the conclusion is one no reasonable person could reach.
Reaffirmed · para 12 · State of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. v. S. Sree Rama Rao, 1963 SCC OnLine SC 6, para 11
Previous misconduct for which an employee has already faced disciplinary action cannot itself be treated as fresh misconduct, though past record may be considered in fixing penalty for independently established misconduct.
Laid down · para 20
The sentence must suit the offence and the offender; it should not be vindictive, unduly harsh, or so disproportionate as to shock the conscience.
Reaffirmed · para 24 · Ranjit Thakur v. Union of India, para 24
Summaries are for information and are not legal advice. Read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.