Skip to main content
H.

Tainted evidence: what an illegal search costs

Published on December 25, 2026

In a corruption case the recovery is the case. Money found in a private place after an entry made without authority will not carry the charge on its own, because the prosecution still has to prove the demand and a tainted recovery cannot supply it. For a defence lawyer, that point has to be forced at the earliest stage of the proceedings, and the ground is usually on the face of the search memorandum.

Where the rule sits after 1 July 2024

The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 replaced the Evidence Act on 1 July 2024, and corroboration is now governed by the Adhiniyam. The earlier Section 27 of the Evidence Act dealt with a confession made to a police officer, which may not be proved against the accused unless it is corroborated by independent evidence of the material facts, and a confession had also to be corroborated by independent witnesses wherever it was recorded. The Adhiniyam now governs both, and its section numbers have to be read in the bare Act before they are cited.

The Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 was not renumbered by the Prevention of Corruption (Amendment) Act, 2018 (16 of 2018), which came into force on 26 July 2018. The sections of the Act that a tainted recovery touches are still where they were. Section 18 governs the inspection of bankers' books, and Section 18A governs attachment.

What an illegal entry does to the money that comes out of the search

A search of a private place carried out without authority, or outside the terms of the authority given, taints what is found. The court then asks a separate question about each item seized. A recovery of currency from a room entered in that way cannot rest on the fact that the money was found in that room. What the file then needs is evidence from a source the search did not produce, connecting the accused to the demand.

The defence accepts that the money was found and takes the ground that the finding proves nothing, because the entry which produced it was not lawful. The prosecution is left to find the rest of its case elsewhere, and in a file built on a single recovery there is often no elsewhere.

Two provisions of the Act decide how much time there is for that argument. Section 4(1) makes the trial before a special Judge the only trial for the offences specified in Section 3(1), and Section 4(4) requires that trial to be held as far as practicable on a day to day basis, with an endeavour to conclude it within a period of two years, extendable by six months at a time for reasons recorded in writing, and the aggregate period not to exceed ordinarily four years.

A trap that was set up irregularly

The trap case has its own rule about the recovery, and it applies whatever the search was. State of Andhra Pradesh v. V. Vasudeva Rao, 2004 (9) SCC 319, decided 13 November 2003, was a trap case in which the complainant Raghunath died before the trial, the complainant had advanced the money to the accused as a hand loan, so the money was recovered from him, and the prosecution case rested on the trap and on the recovery of currency marked with phenolphthalein. The High Court directed an acquittal and the State appealed. The Court recorded that where the evidence on the record does not establish any demand, mere recovery would not suffice, and that the presence of the phenolphthalein powder is not an incriminating circumstance.

Two things follow for a file in which the trap was staged irregularly. A recovery of marked currency from the complainant's own pocket, or from the accused with nothing else on the record to show the demand, will not carry the case. And the presumption in Section 20 cannot supply the missing demand: it operates only where it is proved that the accused has accepted or obtained or attempted to obtain, for himself or for any other person, any undue advantage from any person, and it then presumes, unless the contrary is proved, that the advantage was obtained as a motive or reward under Section 7 for performing a public duty improperly or dishonestly.

What an appellate court does with a tainted recovery

Renuka Prasad v. The State represented by Assistant Superintendent of Police, 2025 INSC 657, decided 9 May 2025, is the decision to read on this question. The Court treated prevaricating witnesses, witnesses turning hostile and an overzealous investigation together, and applied the principle that the presumption of innocence available to the accused stands fortified and strengthened by reason of an order of acquittal, and that where there are two probable views the one favourable to the accused ought to be taken.

"Prevaricating witnesses, turning hostile in Court and overzealous investigations, done in total ignorance of basic tenets of criminal law, often reduces prosecution to a mockery." Renuka Prasad v. The State, 2025 INSC 657.

That judgment also relies on two earlier decisions of the Court, one of them the decision in Sunil v. State of NCT of Delhi, 2023 INSC 840, which is Criminal Appeal No. 688 of 2011 (Sunil) with Criminal Appeal No. 689 of 2011 (Ravinder). It is a decision on tainted evidence and on the need for an independent recovery, and the terms on which the Court required that independent recovery are in the report, which should be read before the point is put up in an appeal.

An appellate court in this situation tests whether the case stands without the tainted material, and where two probable views are open on the record the view favourable to the accused is the one taken.

The forum for that review is fixed by Section 27 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, which allows the High Court to exercise, so far as they may be applicable, the powers of appeal and revision conferred by the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974) on a High Court, as if the court of the special Judge were a court of Session trying cases within the local limits of the High Court.

What the defence should do at the earliest stage

The earliest stage in the file is the discharge hearing, and Section 22(a) of the Act fixes what is put before the court at that hearing. It modifies Section 243 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 so that the accused is required to give in writing, at once or within such time as the court may allow, a list of the persons, if any, whom he proposes to examine as his witnesses and of the documents, if any, on which he proposes to rely, and then the accused is called upon. A document left out of that list is out of the defence's hands at the start of the case.

The taintedness ground belongs in the same application, and the papers for it are:

  • the search memorandum, with the seizure memo and the inventory showing what was taken and where each item was found.
  • the authority under which the search was made, with the time of entry and the persons present at the time.
  • the trap memorandum and the statement of the complainant, with the statement of the officer who carried out the search.
  • the proof of the source of the money recovered, showing how it came to be in the place where it was found.
  • the certified copies of the bank entries, with the record of how they were obtained under Section 18, including the special authorisation where the police officer was below the rank of Superintendent of Police.
  • the attachment order and the record of the proceedings taken under Section 18A.

Section 18A(1) applies the provisions of the Criminal Law Amendment Ordinance, 1944 (Ord. 38 of 1944), as far as may be, to the attachment, administration of attached property and execution of order of attachment or confiscation of money or property procured by means of an offence under this Act, save as otherwise provided under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (15 of 2003), and Section 18A(2) reads a reference to the District Judge as a reference to the Special Judge. A tainted recovery can carry an attachment, and the challenge to the attachment is taken when the attachment is made rather than after the property has been dealt with.

Section 18 is how money in an account is proved, and it carries conditions of its own. A police officer empowered to investigate under Section 17, who has reason to suspect an offence and considers it necessary for the investigation, may inspect bankers' books so far as they relate to the accounts of the person suspected or of any other person suspected to be holding money on that person's behalf, take certified copies of the relevant entries, and the bank is bound to assist him. An attack on the raid leaves those conditions unexamined, so the Section 18 record belongs in the file.

Section 21 of the Act bears on the same stage. A person charged with an offence punishable under the Act is a competent witness for the defence and may give evidence on oath in disproof of the charges, provided that he shall not be called as a witness except at his own request, and that his failure to give evidence is not to be the subject of comment by the prosecution or to give rise to any presumption against himself.

Where taintedness is cured and where it is not

Taintedness is cured where the foundation of the case is placed somewhere the search did not reach. An independent recovery of the money, money found again from the accused in circumstances that do not come out of the illegal entry, and independent evidence of the demand, are what a prosecution needs. The presumption in Section 20 cannot do that work: it operates only where it is proved that the accused has accepted or obtained or attempted to obtain an undue advantage, and Paritala Sudhakar v. State of Telangana, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1072, holds that where the demand is not proved it does not operate against the accused, and that the accused is entitled to the benefit of doubt.

Taintedness is not cured by the prosecution examining the same seized material again in a different order. The exceptions to the rule, and the conditions on which a tainted item may still be used, are to be read in the reports and in the bare Act of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, because the Adhiniyam now governs the corroboration rules that decide the question and the section number has to be read there before it is cited.

What the file should carry before the next hearing

Before the next hearing the file should carry the search memorandum, the seizure memo, the trap memorandum, the Section 18 records of the bank entries and the Section 22(a) list of witnesses and documents. The corroboration provision of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 should be read in the bare Act, because the number has to be right before it is cited in a discharge application. The list under Section 22(a) is given at once or within such time as the court may allow, and a ground left to the appellate court is a ground the trial court has already let pass.

The law in this article was last checked against the research database on 12 November 2026.

Tags:Prevention of Corruption ActEvidenceSearch and SeizureCriminal TrialTainted Evidence