Skip to main content
H.

Service law · Art. 141 · Judgment of

Court holds its OBC creamy-layer ruling binds parties only and cannot reopen concluded selections.

The facts

  • Respondent candidates who cleared the Civil Services Examination were denied OBC non-creamy layer benefits because DoPT applied the income test under the 1993 OM read with the 2004 Letter to their PSU-employed parents.
  • They succeeded before the CAT and the High Courts, and this Court dismissed the Union's civil appeals on 11.03.2026, directing implementation within six months.
  • The Union filed miscellaneous applications seeking prospective operation of the judgment, time to establish equivalence of posts, and protection for completed selections, appointments and admissions.
  • The CSE-2025 result was declared on 06.03.2026, but service allocation remained pending when the applications were heard.

What the Court held

The binding force of a legal principle declared under Article 141 is distinct from the scope of the operative relief, which remains confined to the parties to the lis.

Laid down · para 13

Other principles

  • Miscellaneous applications cannot be used to seek a rehearing or reconsideration of merits; they lie only for correcting clerical or arithmetical errors or resolving genuine implementation difficulties.

    Reaffirmed · para 16

  • A ratio laid down by the Court does not by itself furnish a ground for reopening selections or appointments already concluded before the judgment, and does not operate to the detriment of others' seniority.

    Laid down · para 18

  • Selections, appointments and roster allotments made after the judgment are governed by the 1993 OM as interpreted by the Court, while policy on equivalence of posts and creamy-layer criteria remains with the executive and legislature.

    Laid down · para 18

Summaries are for information and are not legal advice. Read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.