Skip to main content
H.

Service law · Art. 14 · Judgment of

Compulsory retirement upheld; uniform criteria applied and uncommunicated adverse entries valid

The facts

  • The appellants were appointed as Peons in 1989 and 1993, promoted to Assistant Grade-III in 2012 and 2013, and regularised in 2015.
  • A Government Circular dated 25 April 2017 directed review of service records of servants with 20 years service or 50 years age for compulsory retirement.
  • A Screening Committee applied uniform numerical scoring to 14 clerical employees and recommended 5, including the appellants, for compulsory retirement on 9 October 2017.
  • The High Court declined to interfere, and the Supreme Court affirmed, finding the parameters uniformly applied and the orders neither punitive nor stigmatic.

What the Court held

An order of compulsory retirement is neither punitive nor stigmatic, so audi alteram partem and Article 311(2) do not apply to it.

Reaffirmed · para 24 · Baikuntha Nath Das & Anr. vs. Chief District Medical Officer, Baripada & Anr., (1992) 2 SCC 299, para 24

Other principles

  • Compulsory retirement rests on the subjective satisfaction of the competent authority, but that satisfaction must be based on valid material on record.

    Reaffirmed · para 25 · Nand Kumar Verma vs. State of Jharkhand & Ors., (2012) 3 SCC 580, para 25

  • An employee cannot assail compulsory retirement merely because another officer with a comparable record was not similarly retired; Article 14 does not countenance negative equality.

    Reaffirmed · para 29

  • The principle that adverse entries lose sting on promotion applies only to entries pre-dating the promotion, not to entries recorded after promotion in the promoted post.

    Laid down · para 39

  • An order of compulsory retirement is not liable to be quashed merely because uncommunicated adverse remarks were also taken into consideration.

    Reaffirmed · para 48

Summaries are for information and are not legal advice. Read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.