Skip to main content
H.

s. 6 · Judgment of

Court excludes outside and temporary residents from FRA claims and orders supervised adjudication

The facts

  • The Court's earlier judgment mandated eviction, rehabilitation and ecological restoration in the Agasthyamalai landscape, including removal of encroachments and action against identified government servants.
  • Applications raised issues about applicability of the FRA, 2006 to persons residing or cultivating in the Megamalai region, and the State was directed to respond on silk cotton cultivation, pattas, action against 118 government servants, and FRA claim status.
  • The State's affidavit classified occupiers into three categories: 1,595 permanently residing in the forest, 232 with temporary residence, and 2,767 residing outside the forest boundary, with 3,637.83 hectares under silk cotton cultivation.
  • Around 40 Gram Sabhas had been constituted and about 1,600 claims received, with the State seeking time to complete the statutory adjudication process.

What the Court held

Claims of FDST and OTFD must be determined strictly through the Section 6 three-tier mechanism read with the Rules, not on the basis of present occupation, and only persons satisfying Sections 2(c) and 2(o) get the Act's benefit.

Laid down · para 55

Other principles

  • Persons cultivating with only temporary residence in the forest or residing outside the forest boundary cannot qualify as FDST or OTFD on the basis of such cultivation alone.

    Laid down · para 64

  • Planned or promoted cultivation of a commercial crop inside forest areas is impermissible as no such right is recognised under the FRA, 2006, since minor forest produce must be naturally occurring.

    Laid down · para 61

  • The FRA, 2006 is a social welfare or remedial statute enacted to recognise and vest forest rights of forest-dwelling STs and other traditional forest dwellers whose rights could not be recorded.

    Reaffirmed · para 44 · Orissa Mining Corpn. Ltd. v. Ministry of Environment & Forests, (2013) 6 SCC 476, para 44

Summaries are for information and are not legal advice. Read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.