Skip to main content
H.

Land Acquisition and Rehabilitation Acts · s. 34 · Judgment of

Acquisition set aside for lacking mandatory prior Gram Sabha consent and 80% family consent under 2013 Act

Editorial illustration on Land Acquisition and Rehabilitation Acts. Court set aside land acquisition for missing mandatory prior Gram Sabha and family consent.
AI-generated illustration.

The facts

  • The State of Odisha initiated land acquisition under the 2013 Act for surface rights over land in three villages, at the instance of a private company holding a mining lease.
  • Gram Panchayats unanimously rejected the proposal in January 2020, and no public hearing on the draft SIA was conducted due to Covid-19 restrictions.
  • The Expert Group included a person connected to the company as Advisor, Land Acquisition, and prior consent of 80% affected families was not obtained before Section 8 examination.
  • The High Court dismissed the writ petition, holding consent requirements were directory and the acquisition substantially compliant; the Supreme Court set aside the acquisition.

What the Court held

Prior consent under Section 2(2)(b) must be obtained along with the SIA study and before the government examines the proposal under Section 8, not as a continuing process throughout acquisition proceedings.

Laid down · para 31

Other principles

  • The requirement of prior Gram Sabha consent under Section 41(3) for land acquisition in Scheduled Areas is mandatory, not directory, and cannot be negated by the directory language of sub-sections (1) and (2).

    Laid down · para 39

  • The Expert Group evaluating the SIA report must be independent under Section 7(1); including a person connected to the project proponent compromises this statutory independence.

    Laid down · para 46

  • The 2013 Act and the MMDR Act operate in distinct spheres and can be harmoniously construed; a mining lease between State and lessee cannot affect third-party landowners' proprietary rights.

    Laid down · para 49

Summaries are for information and are not legal advice. Read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.