Skip to main content
H.

Constitution of India · Art. 14 · Judgment of

Validation Acts reproducing the exclusion struck down in Prem Singh held constitutionally infirm

Editorial illustration on Constitution of India. The Court struck down Validation Acts that merely reproduced the exclusion struck down earlier.
AI-generated illustration.

The facts

  • Employees of Uttar Pradesh departments, engaged as work-charged, daily-wage or muster-roll staff from the late 1970s and later regularised, claimed that pre-regularisation service count towards pension.
  • In Prem Singh, this Court read down Rule 3(8) of the 1961 Rules, holding work-charged service as qualifying service for pension, with arrears restricted to three years; review was dismissed.
  • The State responded with a 2020 Ordinance and Validation Act, 2021, then a 2025 Ordinance and Validation Act, 2025, retrospectively excluding non-substantive appointees from pension and validating past denials notwithstanding court judgments.
  • The Court examined whether these validating enactments removed the constitutional defect identified in Prem Singh or merely reproduced the same exclusion in new statutory language.

What the Court held

A validating enactment must be tested not only against general constitutional compliance but also against whether it removes the specific defect identified in the earlier judgment.

Laid down · para 58

Other principles

  • The legislature may change the law but may not, under the guise of changing the law, command that a final judicial determination be treated as though it had never been made.

    Laid down · para 70 · Madan Mohan Pathak, para 71

  • Validating enactments that extinguish the operative effect of a final adjudication without removing the legal defect on which it was premised are constitutionally infirm.

    Laid down · para 72

  • Mere non-consideration of an earlier decision does not furnish a sustainable basis for not following its ratio, and per incuriam cannot be invoked on that ground alone.

    Laid down · para 109

Summaries are for information and are not legal advice. Read the full judgment before relying on it. See also our disclaimer.